Book Review: Mary Swann

Mary Swann

by Carol Shields

Mary Swann1

This engrossing novel unravels the story of an ordinary woman who wrote poems – beautiful lines written on scraps of paper by a farmer’s wife. And it seems that is exactly all she was – a poet.  Yet the four major characters are involved in trying to discover who the “real” Mary Swann was. The actual “story” is more a character study – as a biographer, a retired editor, a librarian and an English professor are revealed to us with regard to their connection to Mary Swann.

These four characters are finely outlined and presented beautifully, without criticism, yet laid bare.   They are all ordinary in their own way. Just as Mary Swann was. One of them (the editor) sums things up nicely: “… the lives of most people are pretty scrappy affairs. And full of secrets and concealments.”

The theme that dominates this book is how people deceive and are deceived, concocting and exaggerating stories in their struggle for recognition and praise, love and respect. In the search for truth they distance themselves ever further from it.  “Forgive me the sin of untruthfulness” says the atheist librarian, Rose. The fact that “ordinariness” can be great is not accepted in our society, so the search for a deeper meaning behind words (or actions) will lead to… what? When meaning is not found, do we invent it? Do we give the words of a poet greater weight and interpret meaningful influences and symbolism?

They all seem aware of their deceit, but are unable to admit it. “I want to live for a time without irony, without rhetoric, in a cool, solid metaphor”, says the professor. When they all come together at the end… well, I must not give away the plot! Let’s just say the ending is triumphant!

This is a great study of human behavior, with a slight wryness, barely susceptible. It is comforting in that it gives ordinariness some kind of significance.


Mary Swann2

Carol Shields is one of my favourite writers – I also liked “Unless” and “Various Miracles“. She won the Pulitzer Prize and was short-listed for the Booker Prize with ‘The Stone Diaries’.

29 thoughts on “Book Review: Mary Swann

  1. Thanks for the good review. I love book reviews, yet find them excruciatingly difficult to write, so truly admire them done well. I enjoyed The Stone Diaries, but I don’t think I’ve read anything else by this author…now I’ll add her yo my list. Thank you!

  2. Thank you for the review. I am not familiar with the author: since she is a Pulitzer winner and almost a Booker one, it shows how reading and writing texts/articles etc has not been advantageous to my intellectual ‘development’ 🙂 ! Off to Booktopia [our version of Amazon but cheaper and faster!!]

  3. “Compelling” – what a great word to describe a book that you’ve really enjoyed! I’m a member of a book club, we do the usual, meet once a month and nominate a new book to read. I think I will add this to my list of choices!

  4. I haven’t read anything by Carol Shields. Sounds interesting though. My reading list keeps getting longer and longer. Oh I love reading!!!! 🙂

  5. Shields is definitely an author on my “must-reads” list! Great review – I’ll have to grab this book from the library! (While I’m there, I’ll grab a copy of The Stone Diaries, too – I’ve been meaning to read that for years…).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.